Urban Arena Wiki:Rich description template - Revision history

Nadia Ali: Undo revision 2858 by Nadia Ali (talk)

2020-07-28T15:18:54Z

Undo revision 2858 by Nadia Ali (talk)

Show changes

Nadia Ali: Blanked the page

2020-07-28T15:18:06Z

Blanked the page

Show changes

Nadia Ali: Undo revision 2854 by Nadia Ali (talk)

2020-07-28T14:08:21Z

Undo revision 2854 by Nadia Ali (talk)

← Older revision		Revision as of 16:08, 28 July 2020
Line 1:		Line 1:
	This intervention has been translated into a brief governance scenario. Take a look at '''~~Biodiversity protection and Social Justice in Collserola Natural Park in Barcelona~~'''		This intervention has been translated into a brief governance scenario. Take a look at '''link to the scenario'''

	== a) Basic characteristics and ambitions of the intervention ==		== a) Basic characteristics and ambitions of the intervention ==

Nadia Ali at 14:06, 28 July 2020

2020-07-28T14:06:46Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 16:06, 28 July 2020
Line 1:		Line 1:
	This intervention has been translated into a brief governance scenario. Take a look at '''~~link to the scenario~~'''		This intervention has been translated into a brief governance scenario. Take a look at '''Biodiversity protection and Social Justice in Collserola Natural Park in Barcelona'''

	== a) Basic characteristics and ambitions of the intervention ==		== a) Basic characteristics and ambitions of the intervention ==

Romane Joly at 06:21, 28 July 2020

2020-07-28T06:21:19Z

Show changes

Nadia Ali: Nadia Ali moved page Rich description template to Urban Arena Wiki:Rich description template

2020-07-27T19:28:08Z

Nadia Ali moved page Rich description template to Urban Arena Wiki:Rich description template

← Older revision	Revision as of 21:28, 27 July 2020
(No difference)

Nadia Ali: /* k) Reflections on important governance concepts */

2020-07-27T19:13:21Z

k) Reflections on important governance concepts

← Older revision		Revision as of 21:13, 27 July 2020
Line 420:		Line 420:
	'''35. What other aspects of governance, that were not covered above, are important to highlight, too?'''		'''35. What other aspects of governance, that were not covered above, are important to highlight, too?'''

	~~answer~~		The initiative aims to build and improve alternatives in parallel to the existing governance structure. A decentralized (economy and) energy system that focuses on supply-driven-demand, not demand-driven-supply.

	'''36. From your perspective as a researcher, which word or phrase characterizes this governance intervention most concisely? (Please attach your name to the characterization) In other words, what is the biggest takeaway from this intervention about governance arrangements?'''		'''36. From your perspective as a researcher, which word or phrase characterizes this governance intervention most concisely? (Please attach your name to the characterization) In other words, what is the biggest takeaway from this intervention about governance arrangements?'''

	~~answer~~		A citizens-driven initiative based on a decentralized bottom-up governance system, standing firm to achieve envisioned goals even when things didn’t work as expected and planned.


	== Appendix 1: Three modes of governance ==		== Appendix 1: Three modes of governance ==

Nadia Ali: /* i) Learning involved in establishing interventions elsewhere (transferability) */

2020-07-27T18:50:29Z

i) Learning involved in establishing interventions elsewhere (transferability)

← Older revision		Revision as of 20:50, 27 July 2020
Line 385:		Line 385:
	*'''a. Have any suggestions been made about a replicability, scaleability or transferability of the intervention? [e.g. in the documentation of the intervention in a project or the press? Links would be perfect]'''		*'''a. Have any suggestions been made about a replicability, scaleability or transferability of the intervention? [e.g. in the documentation of the intervention in a project or the press? Links would be perfect]'''

	~~answer~~		BEB is a replication of another cooperative from the town of Schönau that successfully purchased the town’s currently operational power grid. A similar initiative has been undertaken in Hamburg. So, it can be said that the initiative is highly replicable, however, transferability/replicability has not been suggested.

	*'''b. Transferability to what kind of contexts has been suggested?'''		*'''b. Transferability to what kind of contexts has been suggested?'''

	~~answer~~		Not reported

	*'''c. Who has made the claims?'''		*'''c. Who has made the claims?'''

	~~answer~~		Not reported.

	*'''d. What limits to transferability to broader contexts have been discussed?'''		*'''d. What limits to transferability to broader contexts have been discussed?'''

	~~answer~~		Not reported

	'''32. In what forms has the learning process, including stories of overcoming obstacles, been recorded for, and/or made accessible to city makers also from elsewhere?<ref>Feel free to include learning that has been made available through EU project documentation, intervention initiatives, or other channels. In addition to the forms in which the learning process has been shared with others, please indicate whether the learning process that’s being shared has been recorded in a self-critical/reflexive way.</ref>		'''32. In what forms has the learning process, including stories of overcoming obstacles, been recorded for, and/or made accessible to city makers also from elsewhere?<ref>Feel free to include learning that has been made available through EU project documentation, intervention initiatives, or other channels. In addition to the forms in which the learning process has been shared with others, please indicate whether the learning process that’s being shared has been recorded in a self-critical/reflexive way.</ref>

	~~answer~~		As part of TESS study, BEB members had been interviewed about the intervention including confronted challenges/obstacles.

	'''33. Have any signs of collaboration, support, or inspiration already been reported between actors involved in this intervention and others that follow its example? (e.g. in “follower cities”?)'''		'''33. Have any signs of collaboration, support, or inspiration already been reported between actors involved in this intervention and others that follow its example? (e.g. in “follower cities”?)'''

	~~answer~~		BEB’s goal has not yet been achieved therefore the replication of the specific intervention has not been recorded.

	== j) Structural learning ==		== j) Structural learning ==

Nadia Ali: /* h) Learning involved in establishing the intervention */

2020-07-27T18:46:40Z

h) Learning involved in establishing the intervention

← Older revision		Revision as of 20:46, 27 July 2020
Line 342:		Line 342:
	*'''a. any previous experiences in the same urban context (e.g. city…) that the intervention is (reportedly) building upon? This could include any relevant experiences in the same or another sector.'''		*'''a. any previous experiences in the same urban context (e.g. city…) that the intervention is (reportedly) building upon? This could include any relevant experiences in the same or another sector.'''

	~~answer~~		No

	*'''b. any inter-city partnerships, or transfers from experiences elsewhere that have (reportedly) been important in the emergence of this intervention?'''		*'''b. any inter-city partnerships, or transfers from experiences elsewhere that have (reportedly) been important in the emergence of this intervention?'''

	~~answer~~		The intervention is building upon a previous experience in the town of Schönau that does not exactly have the same context - Schönau is a small town whereas Berlin is a state city.

	=== Learning content ===		=== Learning content ===
Line 354:		Line 354:
	*'''a. from previous experiences in the same urban context'''		*'''a. from previous experiences in the same urban context'''

	~~answer~~		Not reported.

	*'''b. from inter-city partnerships, or transfers from experiences elsewhere'''		*'''b. from inter-city partnerships or transfers from experiences elsewhere'''

	~~answer~~		EWS Schönau has been instrumental in the success of BEB through passing on knowledge and expertise. In order to reach out to people and inform them about the cooperative they worked together with the media, organized so-called “NetzGipfel” (Network Summits), and took part in demonstrations and other events to inform people about their initiative and to get more participants. One of the founders of Schönau is a board member of BEB.

	*'''c. from other knowledge gathering/research'''		*'''c. from other knowledge gathering/research'''

	~~''answer''~~		Not reported.

	=== Learning process ===		=== Learning process ===
Line 368:		Line 368:
	'''28. In what ways has the intervention been adapted to specific circumstances of the targeted urban context based on the learned content reported in question 27?'''		'''28. In what ways has the intervention been adapted to specific circumstances of the targeted urban context based on the learned content reported in question 27?'''

	~~answer~~		The intervention had not been replicated elsewhere yet.

	'''29. Based on your answers to question 24, how has overcoming obstacles (reportedly) contributed to the learning process?'''		'''29. Based on your answers to question 24, how has overcoming obstacles (reportedly) contributed to the learning process?'''

	~~answer~~		Not reported

	'''30. Please list any tools that enabled the learning process (e.g. various Knowledge Brokerage Activities from pg. 24 of FOODLINK’s Deliverable 7.1 - linked in footnote)<ref>http://www.foodlinkscommunity.net/fileadmin/documents_organicresearch/foodlinks/publications/karner-etal-d-7-1.pdf		'''30. Please list any tools that enabled the learning process (e.g. various Knowledge Brokerage Activities from pg. 24 of FOODLINK’s Deliverable 7.1 - linked in footnote)<ref>http://www.foodlinkscommunity.net/fileadmin/documents_organicresearch/foodlinks/publications/karner-etal-d-7-1.pdf
	.</ref> and the actors involved in using them.'''		.</ref> and the actors involved in using them.'''

	~~answer~~		Not reported

	== i) Learning involved in establishing interventions elsewhere (transferability)==		== i) Learning involved in establishing interventions elsewhere (transferability)==

Nadia Ali: /* g) Reported outcomes */

2020-07-27T18:23:29Z

g) Reported outcomes

← Older revision		Revision as of 20:23, 27 July 2020
Line 326:		Line 326:
	BEB has not reached its goal of purchasing the Berlin energy grid, thus its success could be measured in terms of its campaigns work, and has started an important discussion on public participation in decisions concerning energy infrastructure.		BEB has not reached its goal of purchasing the Berlin energy grid, thus its success could be measured in terms of its campaigns work, and has started an important discussion on public participation in decisions concerning energy infrastructure.
	Below are some achievements of the milestones accomplished by BEB:		Below are some achievements of the milestones accomplished by BEB:
	Collection of 11 million Euros in 2015 (100 million Euros is the target) to buy 25% of the energy grid.		*Collection of 11 million Euros in 2015 (100 million Euros is the target) to buy 25% of the energy grid.
	Increase in the rate of membership (therefore funding too), campaign sponsorships, a number of volunteers, and media attention are the biggest achievements of BE.		*Increase in the rate of membership (therefore funding too), campaign sponsorships, a number of volunteers, and media attention are the biggest achievements of BE.
	Success in the future would mean to be a shareholder of the energy grid in Berlin or at a cooperation partner, supplying renewable energy (TESS 5, pg. 16).		*Success in the future would mean to be a shareholder of the energy grid in Berlin or at a cooperation partner, supplying renewable energy (TESS 5, pg. 16).
	Besides, in 2019 the "Landesbetrieb Berlin Energie" won the procurement procedure which is a victory on the way to remunicipalisation.		Besides, in 2019 the "Landesbetrieb Berlin Energie" won the procurement procedure which is a victory on the way to remunicipalisation.