Commit to a meaningful participation process - Revision history

Sophia McRae at 10:32, 5 March 2021

2021-03-05T10:32:01Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 12:32, 5 March 2021
Line 1:		Line 1:
			<embedvideo service="youtube" alignment="right" dimensions="480">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i9gdMhQ52XA</embedvideo>

	[[File:4 Commit To A Meaningful Participation.jpg.jpeg\|600x600x\|thumb\|Commit to a Meaningful Participation Process]]		[[File:4 Commit To A Meaningful Participation.jpg.jpeg\|600x600x\|thumb\|Commit to a Meaningful Participation Process]]

Sophia McRae at 10:16, 4 March 2021

2021-03-04T10:16:56Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 12:16, 4 March 2021
Line 1:		Line 1:
	[[File:4 Commit To A Meaningful Participation.jpg.jpeg\|600x600x\|thumb\|Commit to a Meaningful Participation Process]]		[[File:4 Commit To A Meaningful Participation.jpg.jpeg\|600x600x\|thumb\|Commit to a Meaningful Participation Process]]

	~~Examples from real world governance interventions:~~

	*[[Co-creation of a sustainable neighborhood in Freiburg]]
	*[[Holistic neighbourhood development Augustenborg]]
	*[[Inner-city community energy in London]]
	*[[Community led affordable housing in Brussels]]
	*[[Regeneration of a deprived neighborhood in Rotterdam]]
	*[[Citizens share in Berlin Energy Grid for sustainable energy]]

	== General ambition ==		== General ambition ==
Line 23:		Line 14:
	''' ''Vauban neighborhood'', Freiburg '''		''' ''Vauban neighborhood'', Freiburg '''

	The citizen-led Vauban Forum was invited to participate in the “Vauban city planning council” (a consultative committee within the city council) which indicates that the municipality recognizes citizens as legitimate partners in the project development (~~Q.15~~ & 22).		The citizen-led Vauban Forum was invited to participate in the “Vauban city planning council” (a consultative committee within the city council) which indicates that the municipality recognizes citizens as legitimate partners in the project development [[Co-creation of a sustainable neighborhood in Freiburg#15. How are responsibilities and/or decision-making power distributed among actors?\|(Q15 & Q22)]].

	Learn more about this intervention:		Learn more about this intervention:
Line 31:		Line 22:
	''' ''Holistic neighbourhood development'', Augustenborg'''		''' ''Holistic neighbourhood development'', Augustenborg'''

	In Augustenborg, all physical changes were discussed in advance with residents, giving them the possibility to express their suggestions and observations, thereby having the possibility to adjust and modify the plan. All actions were agreed on together with residents. Some aspects of the project were co-designed by residents, as they were considered as experts and bearers of specific and territorially grounded knowledge. In total, approximately, approximately 20% of the residents participated in the project. Several of their ideas were implemented into the neighbourhood, such as developing the open storm water system in a more natural process that enhances the area’s urban biodiversity (Q14)		In Augustenborg, all physical changes were discussed in advance with residents, giving them the possibility to express their suggestions and observations, thereby having the possibility to adjust and modify the plan. All actions were agreed on together with residents. Some aspects of the project were co-designed by residents, as they were considered as experts and bearers of specific and territorially grounded knowledge. In total, approximately, approximately 20% of the residents participated in the project. Several of their ideas were implemented into the neighbourhood, such as developing the open storm water system in a more natural process that enhances the area’s urban biodiversity [[Holistic neighbourhood development Augustenborg#14. To what extent, in what form and at what stages have citizens participated in the shaping of the intervention?\|(Q14)]].
	Key here was to strike a good balance between short-term change of the area (where residents see fast changes as a result of their own participation) and long-term commitment of institutions (so residents see a bigger vision behind the project and feel like their time and energy will contribute to something greater) (Q23).		Key here was to strike a good balance between short-term change of the area (where residents see fast changes as a result of their own participation) and long-term commitment of institutions (so residents see a bigger vision behind the project and feel like their time and energy will contribute to something greater) [[Holistic neighbourhood development Augustenborg#23. What obstacles to implementing the intervention (both generally, and in this particular context) have been identified, relating to:\|(Q23)]].

	Learn more about this intervention:		Learn more about this intervention:
Line 42:		Line 33:
	''' ''Repowering'', London'''		''' ''Repowering'', London'''

	Citizens have been the founders and drivers of the intervention from the very beginning. The intervention’s cooperative structure relies upon community engagement in order to function (financial investment, regular meetings, decision-making etc.) and the intervention engages with a wider community base in order to address energy poverty and provide opportunities for employment and learning (Q14). Additionally, further consultation with local residents informed the initiative’s problem definition (deliberative approach), and hands-on involvement (practical approach) in the creation of solar panels and internships led to increased interest and participation (Q.24).		Citizens have been the founders and drivers of the intervention from the very beginning. The intervention’s cooperative structure relies upon community engagement in order to function (financial investment, regular meetings, decision-making etc.) and the intervention engages with a wider community base in order to address energy poverty and provide opportunities for employment and learning [[Inner-city community energy in London#14. To what extent, in what form and at what stages have citizens participated in the shaping of the intervention?\|(Q14)]]. Additionally, further consultation with local residents informed the initiative’s problem definition (deliberative approach), and hands-on involvement (practical approach) in the creation of solar panels and internships led to increased interest and participation [[Inner-city community energy in London#24. What has been done by each central actor group to overcome which particular obstacles in the way of successfully implementing the intervention? (this may include institutional Work - maintaining, disrupting, and creating new rules, applying to both formal laws/regulations and informal norms and expectations.)\|(Q24)]].

	Learn more about this intervention:		Learn more about this intervention:
Line 50:		Line 41:
	''' ''Community Land Trust'', Brussels'''		''' ''Community Land Trust'', Brussels'''

	Future building residents are essential actors in the planning process. From a very early stage they are central in visioning and realizing the creation of their future community land trust home. Furthermore, residents make up one third of the Trust’s board members (Q.14).		Future building residents are essential actors in the planning process. From a very early stage they are central in visioning and realizing the creation of their future community land trust home. Furthermore, residents make up one third of the Trust’s board members [[Community led affordable housing in Brussels#14. To what extent, in what form and at what stages have citizens participated in the shaping of the intervention?\|(Q.14)]].

	Learn more about this intervention:		Learn more about this intervention:
Line 88:		Line 79:
	''' ''Vauban neighborhood'', Freiburg '''		''' ''Vauban neighborhood'', Freiburg '''

	In Vauban, housing was primarily accessible to homeowners rather than to tenants. Indeed, about 76% of the district is dedicated to homeowners (including cooperatives). However, becoming an owner is not accessible to everyone because it entails very high entry costs. Additionally, building one's own house takes a lot of time (at least 5 years), which not everybody can afford (~~Q.14~~)		In Vauban, housing was primarily accessible to homeowners rather than to tenants. Indeed, about 76% of the district is dedicated to homeowners (including cooperatives). However, becoming an owner is not accessible to everyone because it entails very high entry costs. Additionally, building one's own house takes a lot of time (at least 5 years), which not everybody can afford [[Co-creation of a sustainable neighborhood in Freiburg#14. To what extent, in what form and at what stages have citizens participated in the shaping of the intervention?\|(Q14)]]

	Learn more about this intervention:		Learn more about this intervention:
Line 96:		Line 87:
	''' ''Carnisse neighborhood'', Rotterdam'''		''' ''Carnisse neighborhood'', Rotterdam'''

	The Resilience Lab took place in the context of withdrawal of the state welfare structures and financial support by redirecting the responsibility to the local inhabitants and citizens. In that sense, the Resilience Lab is a solution given the context of a required “participatory society” (Q20).		The Resilience Lab took place in the context of withdrawal of the state welfare structures and financial support by redirecting the responsibility to the local inhabitants and citizens. In that sense, the Resilience Lab is a solution given the context of a required “participatory society” [[Regeneration of a deprived neighborhood in Rotterdam#20. According to project material/and or interviews, in what ways have particularities of (local) political culture influenced the character and success of the intervention? (i.e. trust in political institutions, citizens’ will to interact with policy makers and vice versa, traditions of cooperation etc.)\|(Q20)]].

	Learn more about this intervention:		Learn more about this intervention:

Sophia McRae at 09:20, 4 March 2021

2021-03-04T09:20:36Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 11:20, 4 March 2021
Line 1:		Line 1:
	[[File:4 Commit To A Meaningful Participation.jpg.jpeg\|~~200x200x~~\|thumb\|Commit to a Meaningful Participation Process]]		[[File:4 Commit To A Meaningful Participation.jpg.jpeg\|600x600x\|thumb\|Commit to a Meaningful Participation Process]]

	Examples from real world governance interventions:		Examples from real world governance interventions:

Sophia McRae at 13:00, 25 February 2021

2021-02-25T13:00:50Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 15:00, 25 February 2021
Line 1:		Line 1:
			[[File:4 Commit To A Meaningful Participation.jpg.jpeg\|200x200x\|thumb\|Commit to a Meaningful Participation Process]]

	Examples from real world governance interventions:		Examples from real world governance interventions:

Sophia McRae at 12:43, 25 February 2021

2021-02-25T12:43:40Z

Show changes

Tom.henfrey: Tom.henfrey moved page 4) Commit to a meaningful participation process to Commit to a meaningful participation process: simplify titles

2021-02-22T09:06:41Z

Tom.henfrey moved page 4) Commit to a meaningful participation process to Commit to a meaningful participation process: simplify titles

← Older revision	Revision as of 11:06, 22 February 2021
(No difference)

Sophia McRae at 12:28, 6 January 2021

2021-01-06T12:28:15Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 14:28, 6 January 2021
Line 33:		Line 33:
	Learn more about this intervention:		Learn more about this intervention:
	* Take a look at the detailed [[Dealing flexibly with and learning from resistance in Barcelona]]		* Take a look at the detailed [[Dealing flexibly with and learning from resistance in Barcelona]]
	* Check out the brief governance scenario called [[Reclaiming ~~street space~~: ~~cooperation~~ for ~~neighbourhood transformation~~]]		* Check out the brief governance scenario called [[Reclaiming Street Space: Cooperation for Neighbourhood Transformation]]

	''2. On the side of civil society''		''2. On the side of civil society''

Sophia McRae at 12:25, 6 January 2021

2021-01-06T12:25:30Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 14:25, 6 January 2021
Line 69:		Line 69:
	Learn more about this intervention:		Learn more about this intervention:
	* Take a look at the detailed [[Citizens share in Berlin Energy Grid for sustainable energy]]		* Take a look at the detailed [[Citizens share in Berlin Energy Grid for sustainable energy]]
	* Check out the brief governance scenario called [[Creating a Sustainable Energy System: a ~~citizen~~-~~driven transformation~~]]		* Check out the brief governance scenario called [[Creating a Sustainable Energy System: a Citizen-Driven Transformation]]

	== Relation to justice in urban sustainability governance ==		== Relation to justice in urban sustainability governance ==

Sophia McRae at 12:21, 6 January 2021

2021-01-06T12:21:53Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 14:21, 6 January 2021
Line 43:		Line 43:
	Learn more about this intervention:		Learn more about this intervention:
	* Take a look at the detailed [[Inner-city community energy in London]]		* Take a look at the detailed [[Inner-city community energy in London]]
	* Check out the brief governance scenario called [[From ~~electricity~~ to ~~empowerment~~: ~~democratizing urban energy systems~~]]		* Check out the brief governance scenario called [[From Electricity to Empowerment: Democratizing Urban Energy Systems]]

	''' ''Community Land Trust'', Brussels'''		''' ''Community Land Trust'', Brussels'''

Sophia McRae: Sophia McRae moved page D) Commit to a meaningful participation process to 4) Commit to a meaningful participation process

2021-01-06T11:58:07Z

Sophia McRae moved page D) Commit to a meaningful participation process to 4) Commit to a meaningful participation process

← Older revision	Revision as of 13:58, 6 January 2021
(No difference)